About | Contact | SUBMIT PRESS | Advertise | FAQ
Spatial Newsletters | Twitter |
HomeNewsArticlesExpertsDataJobsEDULBSSTOREEVENTSDirectoryBLOGPHOTOSSocial Media
Software | Spotlights on Geospatial Data | Web Services | Mashup Zone | IMAGING | Hardware | Social Media  
advertisement

Top Geo News
Put Your News here! 
Social Connect




vimeostumble


Facebook

GISuser Sponsor


Recent Site Additions
Featured Webinar
Featured Video


GISuser TOP 10 Viewed Videos
More Photos and Videos

GIS Job Opportunities
 

Loads of GIS Jobs!

GIS Analyst
Data Processor
Software Developer
Support Analyst - Database
Applications Prototype Specialist–Web Development
Research Assistant for Geographic Information Centre
Academic Associate in Geographic Information Centre
Director of Mobile Product and Technology (Denver)
Subject Matter Expert — Infrastructure Industry - 12WD11118
GIS Analyst Senior
GISuser Sponsor

Directory
Loqly 
Category: Social Networking and Social Location Services


GISuser Sponsor


AnyGeo - Anything Geospatial

↑ Grab this Headline Animator

GISuser RSS Feed
Home arrow Articles arrow Software arrow Commentary and More on Usability and Sharing - Just Keep It Simple Stupid (KISS)     

Feature - Using QR Codes to Deliver Maps Electronically
HOT JOB
post a GIS job * JOB OPPS * Subject Matter Expert, Autodesk CA / GIS Developer, VA
FEATURE - Using Social Media and Twitter To Land The Perfect Job
Submit Your GIS/Geo News/PR to GISuser
Commentary and More on Usability and Sharing - Just Keep It Simple Stupid (KISS)  E-mail
Written by @gletham   
22 September 2010

An interesting topic of discussion at the GIS in the Rockies event was that of usability. This topic was brought up by Peter Batty in his Ignite Spatial NOCO presentation the night before the event kicked off, and appropriately, Batty discussed usability during his keynote - very appropriate in my opinion.

GIS and Geo technology in general has suffered from usability issues greatly over the years and still this is a huge topic and area of concern. Indeed, GIS pros are very good at making things (apps, websites, services, very complex, often complex to the point that users are scared off of they merely adopt only a small percent of the total functionality - once again we can look at the example of MS Office and how 90% of users likely only use up to 10% of the functionality - enter a huge usability issue! No doubt you can thing about ArcGIS, ArcView, Manifold, MapInfo, or whatever platform you desire... I guarantee that  if you really look hard, many of you are lucky of you've ever come close to utilizing even 30% of the functionality available to you.

In an effort to prove his point, Batty went through a short demo where he was attempting to use a GIS database in order to obtain the attribute value of interest to his scenario. He walk through a series of steps, eventually getting the information he wanted, this taking him 10 clicks of the mouse! Batty then contrasted this with a short demo using Ubisense myWorld (Batty is a founder of Ubisense) and got to the same information simply with one click of the mouse. Perhaps the scenario was a little exagerated, however, it really wasn't that hard to believe and there's no doubt you've experienced a similar issue using a GIS application or web service.

After some discussion, Batty offered up an interesting tidbit of Rules for usability:

  • Do usability testing!
  • Put the application in front of users, shut-up, watch them!
  • Give a short list of user scenarios and examples to watch

In an interesting, real-life example, Batty contrasted a current scenario of wildfire webmaps, one being a simple, yet effective Tweet map showing real-time [almost] tweets of interest  the other being an IMS site of wildfire information that was much more cluttered with icons and options, and as a result, much less intuitive to the user - in common, traditional GIS fashion, the application was far more complex than it really needed to be - this the result of packaging loads of functionality, although most users would only be interested in one or 2 options.

Seems to me that the KISS rule (Keep It Simple Stupid!) has been forgotten over the years by the GIS industry! Perhaps one of the most common examples of this today might be the adoption and the reluctance of adoption of OpenStreetMap (OSM), a fabulous, crowd-sourced solution to build accurate, useful basemaps for use as a starting point in GIS apps and services. While OSM has clearly simplified the data collection process by reducing much beurocratic red tape, expensive data collection methods, and eliminate storing the data in a closed, proprietary format. 

Interesting to note, in a panel session at GIS in the Rockies concerning government data and data sharing I picked up on a few interesting tidbits that were mentioned. I found it interesting (or should I say disturbing) that the mindset of the speakers (from Government agencies) concerning several very common resources being used by GIS professionals around the World were fearful, closed-minded, and taking me back to the 1980s! Some of the interesting tidbits picked up on include:

  • mention that the National Map project could go away
  • a mindset about crowd-sourcing where it's thought that when everyone is responsible nobody is responsible
  • and perhaps the most troubling, a Federal agency data steward felt that crowd sourcing presents a vulnerability to us and that OSM will NEVER be the authoratative source
  • See this article by Bill Dollins who was also at the session

See also Peter Batty GIS in the Rockies Keynote - GIS coming out of the closet

 
< Prev   Next >

Submit Your GIS/Geo News/PR to GISuser



Search the Spatial Media Web Resources
Developer Tip
PhoneGap - OpenSource Devlopment Framework; Deploy to 7 Major Mobile Platforms
 
HOT Devices
Introducing the RAMPAGE 6 Rugged Notepad with Android 
Social Media Tips
Using Social Media and Twitter To Land The Perfect Job - Tips, Tricks, Trends - Finding a job can be a daunting task but it doesn't have to be. Many are turning to social media, in particular Twitter, to help score a new gig.
 

deliciousrssnewsletterlinkedinfacebooktwitter

More GISuser Features

feature articlesSee more GISuser Features HERE / See GISuser Spotlights Here

AnyGeo - Geospatial Updates from Glenn

↑ Grab this Headline Animator

Recent Directory Listings
1. SAIC GeoRover Mobile
    Category: GIS for Tablets - iPad and Android Tablet Geo Solutions
    Created: May 22, 2012
2. Arvada Colorado OpenData
    Category: OpenGov and OpenData
    Created: May 21, 2012
3. Colorado OpenData
    Category: OpenGov and OpenData
    Created: May 21, 2012
4. Inlailawatash Forestry...
    Category: Geo Tech Companies & Consultants
    Created: May 15, 2012
5. CSU Fresno
    Category: Distance Learning, Online GIS Education
    Created: May 10, 2012
Show more...
Featured Events

 List Your Event Here 

2X A Week Newsletter

See Recent edition
newsletter

subscribe GISuser

We won't share your address!
Sponsor

Popular Stuff!


RSS and Feeds

Software

software reviews
Geo Technology Software

GISuser Site Sponsor


Most Popular
GISuser HOT Spots!

Google Mashup Zone
GISuser WebMaps
Free Data Articles
Spotlights & Tips
GISuser Resumes
Data Links
10 Cool Things
The LBS Zone!

Partner Sites


lbszone.com


symbianone

A Spatial Media LLC property

 




Spatial Media, LLC ©2003 - 2011 All rights reserved / Privacy Statement